Eleven Months Part 7: Master Hakuin and Elul.
The Zen master Hakuin was praised by his neighbors as one living a pure life.
A beautiful Japanese girl whose parents owned a food store lived near him. Suddenly, without any warning, her parents discovered she was with child.
This made her parents very angry. She would not confess who the man was, but after much harassment at last named Hakuin.
In great anger the parents went to the master. “Is that so?” was all he would say.
After the child was born it was brought to Hakuin. By this time he had lost his reputation, which did not trouble him, but he took very good care of the child. He obtained milk from his neighbors and everything else the little one needed.
A year later the girl-mother could stand it no longer. She told her parents the truth – that the real father of the child was a young man who worked in the fishmarket.
The mother and father of the girl at once went to Hakuin to ask his forgiveness, to apologize at length, and to get the child back again.
Hakuin was willing. In yielding the child, all he said was: “Is that so?”
– Paul Reps and Nyogen Senzaki, Zen Flesh, Zen Bones p. 7. Also on 101 Zen Stories
I will get to this story later. First, some background:
I loved my ex wife from the moment I saw her. I was 17 and she was the most beautiful girl I could ever have imagined meeting. I loved her smile and her laugh and her deadpan sense of humor.
I loved her intensely, powerfully, helplessly. I loved her when we were together and I loved her for long stretches when we were apart. I loved her through relationships with other women. I clung to her. I loved everything about her, except for her. I wanted her to be someone else, someone she couldn’t be.
We have been divorced for seven years and I have spent much of those years making excuses: She wasn’t available to me, she was too involved in her medical training, she moved us too much, she didn’t respect my goals. The list goes on.
The truth is that what I wanted from her was to rescue me from my pain. From my unhappy childhood. From my lack of confidence. From everything I hated about myself. When she couldn’t do this, I got angry and stayed angry.
I would get angry at her for not paying enough attention to me, for not being there for me, for not loving me enough.
I was wrong. She was there. The person I thought she should be wasn’t. But I couldn’t see that because I was so caught up in what I wanted. In reality, she wanted me to succeed, she wanted me to be happy and fulfilled, she wanted me to be her child’s father.
She didn’t stop trying until it became impossible for her to keep trying. Our son was a baby and she realized how much it would damage him if he grew up in a home with parents who fought as much as we did. Finally she asked me to leave because she couldn’t do that to him. And she hated doing it. She hated me for not being able to come through for her.
I’m not writing this to say it was entirely my fault that our marriage ended—things are always more complex than that. I am not writing this to say that I still grieve for our marriage—I don’t. Both of us are much happier now, and our son is happy and confident—a wonderful kid. Things have turned out pretty well.
I am writing this because it’s the beginning of the Jewish month of Elul. It is time for me to engage in my heshbon hanefesh, my soul’s accounting. What have I carried around within myself for the past year (or years) that I can let go of? This year during Elul, I have made a deal with myself to begin working very hard to see the world as it is and not how I want it to be. This is not easy, but it is necessary. It means coming to some difficult realizations, like understanding how much my ex-wife really loved me for me, and how I didn’t return that. It means welcoming in all my emotions and experiences, the good and the bad, and accepting that neither the good nor the bad experiences and emotions are the whole of my existence—that both are impermanent.
Master Hakuin is going to be my guide this month. He just accepted things with equanimity.
Think about it: He lived a pure life and he was accused of doing something impure. He must have been angry. I’m sure he was. But he didn’t throw a tantrum and shout “It isn’t fair!” He just accepted his anger along with the situation and said “Is that so?” Is that how it is? Okay, that’s how it is. I will move on and do what needs to be done. His reputation was ruined but he still needed to be a part of the community so he could provide for the baby.
When the girl and her parents came to apologize, he must have been relieved, and maybe angry too. But he didn’t say “See? I told all of you that I was not the kind of monk who would go around getting young women pregnant, but no one believed me!”
When they took the child back he must have been heartbroken. He had cared for the baby for a year, watched her grow and smile and take her first steps. But he didn’t scream “How could you take this child from me now? I have been caring for her! Where have you been, you stupid people? You are breaking my heart!” He just said “Is that so?” Is that how it’s going to be now? I’m going to be heartbroken. I’m going to miss her. That is part of my life now.
Elul is about looking back and letting go of those times when we’ve fallen short of that equanimity and, not being a Zen master, I have fallen short a lot. Heshbon hanefesh is called an accounting, but it’s not about tallying as much as it’s about accepting. It’s a letting go, but a strange one because it’s about welcoming those things of which we are letting go.
Honestly, heshbon hanefesh is more like meditation than accounting. During meditation we are taught not to stop thinking, but to allow our thoughts to arise as they will, to welcome them, but not to follow them. Instead, we observe them and let them fall away. That’s what we are doing, maybe on a slightly bigger scale, during Elul. We are allowing our lives over the past year arise as they will, we are observing them and letting them fall away. When I do this on the meditation cushion I get up feeling clearer and refreshed—ready to move through the day. My hope is that when I move out of Elul and into Rosh Hashanah, I will feel similarly ready to move through another year of my life.
Think that Hakuim would be amused at the accusation and not angry. He understood that his reputation was ruined the moment the words left the daughter’s lips.
“Is that so?”
The child that was presented to him for his “indiscretion” became far more important to him than anything else. The care and feeding is only a small portion. Showing the value of humanity through the life lived of pure virtue has value beyond living that virtue.
When the truth finally came to light, Hakuim was “willing” to allow the child to return to the family. His reputation restored and, as I believe, his virtuous nature now revered. I like to think that Hakium did this because the child needed to be guided no matter who the father was. It could be said that Hakuim did this because he knew it would be to his own benefit.
I am glad that you are starting this journey. I hope that you find what you are looking for. I also like to think that you are doing this to benefit “E.” But I know that this will pay dividends far beyond your own virtue.
I think you make a great point about Hakuin’s virtue being greater than his own–he demonstrates the virtues of being human, being loving, understanding that what happens to us is nowhere near as big as we truly are.
I think this journey itself is what I’m looking for–it’s been good for me as a parent and a person to try to pay closer attention to those lessons I am being taught as I move through this life.
I’m really grateful for your insights, kindness, and encouragement as I move along my path, and I’m touched by the fact that you are sharing what you’ve learned with me.
Today I felt the need to revisit your post and the replies.
I am a bit frustrated with how things are and how I want them to be lately. I know they are going to be changing eventually. My heart yearns for it to happen sooner (like now) rather than later (like in 2 months.)
I needed to re-read the tale of Master Hakuin’s virtue and let it play in my head a bit longer.
I can either be Master Hakuin or the grandparents of the child.
I am stuck in an unusual situation where for several days a week I am stretched to a near breaking point followed by near isolation. Between the two I need to work out pieces of a relationship with my wife and daughter. Circumstance dictates that I must be in this world of extremes until a threshold has been met or I make the drastic changes.
The quiet way is to wait until the threshold has been met. It will be better and less damage will occur all the way around. It would be the preferred way of moving but I miss my wife and long for her company (we are separated for 3 days a week because of work related issues.)
The drastic way is to make things happen. Force my will on the situation and let the chips fall where they may. My past experience dictates that when I force my will on anything it becomes a disaster. Doing so will solve the longing issue but at a cost.
Virtue versus emotion.
What is the balance? What is correct? What is the cost?
Thanks for letting me ponder my situation,
I had written a very long reply to this, but then WordPress basically ate it.
I think that’s okay though, because what I wanted to tell you was that emotion is not permanent, but virtue is. Virtue is who you really are, I think. Emotions last for 90 seconds unless we allow them to take over.
You are allowed your longing, your frustration over what sounds like a situation worthy of longing and frustration. You can let them in the front door to hang out for a while. They just need to understand that they are expected to be good guests. They aren’t allowed to trash the place. I say that a lot to myself. probably to other people too.
I hope this answer helps you as much as your original message helped me.
I know the path I need to take.
It is important to let the emotion exist and even tell the truth of the situation without taking it over.
This morning I pondered the life of John Frances. He is a man who stopped (literally) talking for 17 years so he could actually listen to what people were saying.
There are times I need to silence my inner voice long enough to listen to myself. The truths of my world, while similar to yours, get blurred by the emotions.
Thanks for the space to wander a bit. I hope I can offer up the same sometime.